Home​NewsMayoral Candidates Clash Over Affordability

Mayoral Candidates Clash Over Affordability

The District’s mayoral race has become a fight over how far government should go to make the city livable again ‒ and how long residents can afford to wait.

All candidates agree on the diagnosis: Washington is becoming unaffordable. Housing costs have soared. Federal job cuts have weakened the tax base. City finances are tightening. And an unpredictable White House and Congress continue to interfere in local affairs.

Where they diverge, sometimes sharply, is on what comes next. Eight candidates are vying to be mayor:

1. Ward 4 Councilmember Janeese Lewis George (janeesefordc.com);

2. former At-Large Councilmember Kenyan McDuffie (kenyanmcduffie.com);

3. developer Gary Goodweather (goodweatherfordc.com);

4. civil rights attorney Yaida Ford (yaida4dc.com);

5. former At-Large Councilmember Vincent Orange (orangeformayor.com);

6. federal contractor Rini Sampath (riniformayor.com);

7. real estate broker Ernest Johnson (ernestformayor2026.com);

8. former federal agent Hope Solomon (hopefordc.com).

This analysis draws on candidate websites, campaign materials and two forums: the March 15 Free DC debate and the April 20 event hosted by The 51st News and Washington Informer.

Shocking Electric Bills

The sharpest confrontations so far have not been about crime or schools but electricity.

At the Free DC debate, McDuffie and Lewis George accused each other of being responsible for the spike in electricity bills. Lewis George pointed out that McDuffie had led the DC Council committee responsible for oversight of the Public Service Commission (PSC), which sets utility rates. McDuffie retorted that both candidates had voted to confirm the current appointees.

“Do not fall for the banana in the tailpipe. It’s about leadership,” McDuffie said, arguing the District’s elected officials shared responsibility for the soaring rates. The clash revealed a deeper split: whether the problem is regulatory failure, political failure or system design.

Their answers at the April 20 Martin Luther King Jr. Library forum, hosted by The 51st News and Washington Informer, showed overlap as well as conflict. Lewis George said she would expand community and government solar options, automatically enroll more residents in low-income utility programs and appoint commissioners who “put people first.” She also wanted to explore “public utility options.” McDuffie likewise backed automatic enrollment and called for a strong People’s Counsel and PSC that prioritize affordability, while also holding data centers responsible for increases.

Both candidates are arguing for a more consumer-protective city posture, though Lewis George’s campaign website goes further in making “affordable utilities for all” a named policy plank.

But Orange saw leverage. Utilities, he declared, always need something from the city. An effective mayor could use any ask as leverage to drive down rates, he argued at the MLK forum.

Goodweather proposes a technological solution in his Power DC plan. It involves expanding local electric production by installing solar panels on all public buildings, recovering sewer heat at DC Water’s sanitation plant, encouraging urban geothermal networks and creating community virtual powerplants. Regional partnerships could be used to lock in stable prices.

Sampath and Solomon each cast the issue as a transparency and governance failure. Sampath said that “Pepco will have to fight to continue to prove” that it should remain the sole utility provider, and criticized “backroom deals and closed door meetings.” Solomon, describing her own experience opening a utility bill “like three times the [usual] cost,” said residents need a mayor who will “figure out what the hell is going on in these backdoor conversations.” Neither campaign’s website offers a utility plan as fleshed out as Goodweather’s or Lewis George’s.

Johnson’s campaign site focuses far more on education, jobs and public safety than on power costs. Where Johnson is specific, it is on broader service delivery and budget alignment rather than a utility strategy.

Making Childcare Affordable

Childcare reveals some of the clearest contrasts in how candidates approach affordability, particularly around cost, access and how to pay for it. Everyone agrees that the average childcare cost of $2,400 per month is excessive. But they disagree on approach.

Lewis George argues for childcare as a public good. Her Childcare for All plan would cap costs at 7% of household income by expanding the city’s subsidy program so that “everybody qualifies, no matter your ZIP Code.” Presenting childcare as a system to be guaranteed rather than supplemented, she said she could raise $500 million to pay for expansion in part by closing loopholes she says benefit Maryland and Virginia businesses.

McDuffie rejected building a new system and prefers the expansion of existing programs, such as the childcare subsidy and universal pre-K. He proposed reducing barriers to opening new providers, including in-home care and downtown facilities. Framing the issue as one of budget priorities, he called the city’s spending plan “a moral document” that should fund programs that already work.

Other candidates focused less on universal coverage and more on system constraints. Orange presented childcare as part of economic development, connecting childcare to both family stability and job creation. At the April 20 debate, he argued that the city should invest in childcare centers not only so parents can work, but also because those centers create jobs and prepare children for school.

At the same debate, Sampath claimed that “provider economics” are a major barrier, arguing that regulations such as limits on where childcare centers can be located make opening and expanding childcare difficult, and she criticized what she described as cuts to childcare funding in the mayor’s budget.

Goodweather took a different approach, linking childcare costs to broader household expenses. His proposal to make transit fare-free, he argued, could return about $1,000 annually to residents, money families could redirect toward childcare, while also building a larger early childhood workforce through his Capital Corps program. Solomon warned that candidates were making promises without honestly explaining “how we’re going to pay for it.” Her answer, while not rejecting childcare funding, stressed budgeting and fiscal choices over a new named plan.

Soaring Housing Costs

Housing is the most fully developed issue across the race, but candidates disagree sharply on pace, scale and whether the city should act mainly as regulator, partner or builder. Lewis George wants to create 72,000 new units in five years through a Dignified Homes DC plan that would drive the increase through a publicly owned, mixed-income and permanent affordable-housing developer. To attain that goal, she wants to simplify permitting, relax height restrictions near Metro stations and generally reform the zoning code. Adding supply, she argues, would bring down rents and housing prices. “This crisis is too big and too serious not to be ambitious,” she declared.

McDuffie criticized Lewis George’s goal as unrealistic. His platform takes a more incremental approach. Using the Housing Trust Fund, he plans to expand housing production by 12,000 units. He also promises to preserve another 20,000 existing affordable apartments. Believing in the power of homeownership, McDuffie wants to fund programs to assist residents in accessing the housing market.

Goodweather sits between the two. He promises to audit DC housing agencies in the first 100 days of his administration. He also supports community land trusts, social housing and targeted tax relief. His Affordable DC plan promises 50,0000 new homes by 2032, 36,000 of them being “truly affordable” units that are legally restricted, voucher supported, part of a community land trust or, alternatively, market units that meet published affordability thresholds at move-in.

Beyond those three, the debate shifts again.

Orange emphasizes execution and experience, pointing to projects like Union Market and NoMa and proposing to use the $100 million Housing Trust Fund to build 1,000 smaller units for entry-level workers. Sampath focuses on process failure. “It takes on average 13 months to fill an affordable housing unit,” she said. “That would never be acceptable in a high performing organization.” Solomon challenges the premise outright. “I’m not that candidate of the build, build, build” approach, she declared, and focuses instead on unlocking existing small-landlord units.

All agree that the District’s economy is not equitable, citing neighborhood disparities, barriers to employment and lack of effective workforce development to connect residents with well-paying employment.

Opportunity for All

While agreeing that DC’s economy does not distribute opportunity evenly, the candidates part ways on whether government should strengthen labor standards, build workforce pipelines, attract employers or do all three. In her platform’s Good Jobs for All, Lewis George proposes raising standards for workers, supporting unions and ensuring that economic growth translates into higher incomes for residents. Rather than focusing primarily on pipelines into business sectors, she emphasizes reshaping the terms of work itself through labor protection, benefits and government-backed investment in job creation. Her emphasis on economic opportunity as inseparable from affordability argues that higher wages and stronger worker protections are necessary to keep residents in the city.

Central to McDuffie’s platform are creating pathways into sectors like technology and expanding opportunities for small businesses, alongside wealth-building programs such as baby bonds. He proposes a Stay in DC fund to keep local shops open, and investment in tech and creative startups. At forums he often connects affordability to economic growth, and his campaign materials outside his site stress support for businesses that anchor neighborhoods.

Goodweather’s approach relies on structure and metrics. He promises to create a citywide service and workforce program, the Capital Corps, to clear pathways into employment, along with an advanced technical center in every ward. His proposed RISE Act would require employers to provide 90 days’ notice when technological changes affect jobs.

Others return to growth itself. Orange touts his role in the development of Union Market and Brentwood. Job creation follows economic development, he argues.

Sampath ties opportunity to government performance. Arguing that permitting delays and service failures retard growth, she says, “We need to be a city that actually works.” Solomon echoes that from a business perspective, pointing to bureaucratic barriers. She emphasizes job access and stability as part of broader efforts to improve quality of life and public safety.

Johnson links long-term economic opportunity with educational performance and emphasizes the need for outcomes such as 95% third-grade reading proficiency, 90% math competency by sixth grade and 85% vocational certification completion,

Despite the city’s straightened finances, candidates have made promises that may increase spending.

Expand Government? Reform Government? Or Both?

All the candidates agree that the District has failed to deliver services efficiently and cost-effectively. They differ on whether to expand government’s role, improve the systems, redesign how government operates or better enforce the current laws.

Lewis George‘s vision is the most radical. Government, she argues, is the primary tool for reducing inequality and lowering costs. The city’s affordability problems are caused by underinvestment and market failure. The solution is more direct public investment when private means fall short. Increased efficiencies in government programs can fund the expansion, she argues. “Working people should not shoulder the burden of balancing the budget,” she said.

For Goodweather, public investment is the solution. His proposal to make public transit free to DC residents could return more than $1,000 annually to regular riders, he argues. Much like Lewis George, he believes savings through increased government efficiency can cover the cost.

Orange takes the call for efficiency a step further. At the April 20 forum, he cited examples of funding he claims is misaligned, from police vacancies to paid family leave and traffic camera revenues, and called for a “revenue alignment commission” to find the money. He argues that the city’s problem is not lack of cash but management.

Taking a more measured approach, McDuffie is not anti-spending but tends to frame programs as things government should scale up if they work rather than create entirely new systems. He pairs a proposal for targeted investments, such as baby bonds, with more effective governance.

Sampath, Solomon and Johnson offer their own versions of that critique. Sampath’s campaign proposes using performance metrics and public dashboards to improve agency functioning. She is particularly focused on 311 and 911 response, and her campaign has built a 311 app. Solomon talks about wanting “a real adult in here” and stresses honest discussion about what can be paid for. Johnson says DC government should work for residents rather than “special interests or outside commuters.”

In the background, the White House and Congress increasingly are interfering in the District’s affairs.

Defending DC

It is time to “stand up for all DC,” says Lewis George. That requires an “inside-outside strategy” that combines litigation, congressional engagement and grassroots organizing. Rather than relying solely on legal challenges or political negotiation, her approach assumes the city must do both. At the April 20 debate, she said that “complying in advance is not a strategy” and argued for using every legal lever with Attorney General Brian Schwalb, while also walking “the halls of Congress” herself and building a federal affairs office inside the executive branch. Her website names this agenda Stand Up for All DC and explicitly calls for rescinding the Metropolitan Police Department (MPD) order that permits officers to work with federal immigration enforcement.

McDuffie also promises to terminate MPD cooperation with immigration enforcement, yet he remains open to working with federal partners on economic development and infrastructure. He is not, however, opposed to litigating to protect the District’s autonomy. “There’s no deal that I would ever cut … that will allow them to terrorize vulnerable residents,” he stated.

Super Home Rule is Goodweather’s initiative to expand the District’s authority over its own laws and budget. He says the city needs a standing system to respond to federal interference. At the April 20 debate, he also said sanctuary protections should be strengthened, that houses of worship and schools should be off limits and that every resident should be protected regardless of status. Home rule is not just a legal principle, he argues, but something to be operationalized through policy, planning and institutional capacity.

Orange is the clearest accommodationist voice. At the April 20 forum, he said DC autonomy and statehood are “non-negotiable,” but also argued that the city must “at least have a dialog and to find the common ground.” His website similarly speaks of “Common Ground with the White House & Congress.” Orange is not afraid to lay a major part of the blame for the District’s subservient status on the Democrats.

Sampath and Solomon each push the discussion in their own direction. Sampath emphasizes protest rights and the need to audit data-sharing across agencies so residents know if cooperation with federal immigration enforcement extends farther than disclosed. Solomon emphasizes negotiation, arguing the city needs someone who can sit across from a hostile administration and protect local interests. Johnson’s site is much thinner here, his campaign gesturing toward resident-first self-government, but home rule is not developed nearly as fully as in the platforms of Lewis George, McDuffie or Goodweather.

Choices

The new mayor will take office at a pivotal moment that requires a balancing of government investments against fiscal constraints, cooperation with the federal overlords with protecting residents or making the most of private markets while choosing public alternatives. The candidates offer different ways forward. A voter’s choice is less about policy details than about direction, about how much change the city is willing to embrace. Build new systems, fix broken ones, enforce existing rules or try to do all three at once?

For more information on the candidates in the Democratic Primary for DC mayor visit www.hillrag.com/2026/04/26/who-is-running-in-the-mayoral-democratic-primary/; or attend the debate at the Hill Center at 921 Pennsylvania Ave. SE on May 5 from 7 to 9 p.m. or on May 9 from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. at Transmission at 1353 H St. N. Visit www.hillrag.com/2026/04/27/hear-the-candidates-attend-the-may-debates for more details.

Daily Updates from HillRag

Related Articles